Gusto payroll software logo

Payroll Comparison 2026

Gusto vs. SurePayroll

SurePayroll is the budget option. Its Full Service plan is $29 a month plus $7 per employee, which is cheaper than Gusto Simple ($49 plus $6) under 20 employees and more expensive above. Its $20 plan makes you file the payroll taxes yourself, and local and multi-state filing cost extra. SurePayroll is also strong for household (nanny) payroll. Gusto includes automatic tax filing and a real benefits marketplace on every plan.

Feature Gusto SurePayroll
Base price $49/mo $29/mo (Full Service) or $20/mo (No Tax Filing)
Per employee $6/employee/mo $7/employee/mo (Full Service) or $4 (No Tax Filing)
Contractor payroll Plan's per-person fee, only in months paid W-2 employees and 1099 contractors on either plan
Payroll tax filing Automatic, all 50 states — included Full Service files; No Tax Filing leaves it to you
Benefits administration Health, dental, vision, 401(k), HRA 401(k), health insurance and workers' comp available
Time tracking Built in (Plus & Premium) Time clock add-on, $5/mo + $3/employee
Intro offer Free setup, no contract 6 free months: every other month in year one
Support Phone, email, chat Live phone and chat support
Best for Small businesses that want payroll + HR + benefits in one place Very small businesses and household employers on a budget

Pricing as of 2026 from each provider's public pricing pages. Confirm current rates before purchasing.

Gusto vs SurePayroll pricing by team size

Both companies publish prices. Gusto Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person, and Plus is $80 a month plus $12 per person. SurePayroll Full Service is $29 a month plus $7 per employee and files your payroll taxes. Its No Tax Filing plan is $20 a month plus $4 per employee, and you file and deposit the taxes yourself.

SurePayroll has the lower base fee and the higher fee per employee, so it wins for small teams and loses for larger ones. The two cost the same at 20 employees ($169 a month). At five employees SurePayroll Full Service is $15 a month cheaper. At 100, Gusto Simple is $80 a month cheaper.

Team size Gusto Simple Gusto Plus SurePayroll Full Service SurePayroll No Tax Filing
5 employees $79/mo $140/mo $64/mo $40/mo
10 employees $109/mo $200/mo $99/mo $60/mo
25 employees $199/mo $380/mo $204/mo $120/mo
50 employees $349/mo $680/mo $379/mo $220/mo
100 employees $649/mo $1,280/mo $729/mo $420/mo

List prices before promotions. Gusto and SurePayroll Full Service include payroll tax filing. SurePayroll No Tax Filing does not. SurePayroll says additional charges per payroll may apply for some services. Gusto checked November 1, 2026, SurePayroll checked November 16, 2026.

What the SurePayroll price leaves out

On Full Service, SurePayroll lists three monthly add-ons: $9.99 for multiple state tax filing, $9.99 for local tax filing and $4.99 for accounting software integration. A business that needs all three pays $24.97 a month more than the table shows.

The No Tax Filing plan is the lowest price on either site, and it is a different product. SurePayroll calculates the taxes, and you are responsible for filing and depositing all of them.

SurePayroll advertises six free months. That is every other month free for your first year. Gusto's offer through this site is a $100 Visa card after your first payroll.

Gusto or SurePayroll: a simple rule

Pick SurePayroll Full Service if you have fewer than 20 employees, no local payroll taxes, and want the lowest bill that still files your taxes. Pick Gusto if you have more than 20 employees, or want time tracking and HR tools in the plan. Pick SurePayroll No Tax Filing only if you or your accountant already file payroll taxes.

Where Gusto wins

  • Automatic tax filing included at the base tier
  • Real benefits marketplace and HR tools
  • More modern employee self-service experience

Where SurePayroll wins

  • Lower price than Gusto Simple under 20 employees
  • Strong niche for household/nanny payroll

The bottom line

SurePayroll competes on price, and under 20 employees its Full Service plan costs less than Gusto Simple. Its cheapest plan leaves tax filing to you, and local and multi-state filing cost extra. Gusto includes tax filing on every plan and adds a real benefits marketplace.

New customers can earn a $100 Visa card for running their first payroll with Gusto. Choose SurePayroll if very small businesses and household employers on a budget.

Gusto vs. SurePayroll — FAQs

Is Gusto cheaper than SurePayroll?

Above 20 employees, yes. SurePayroll Full Service is $29 a month plus $7 per employee and Gusto Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person, so they cost the same at 20 employees. Below that SurePayroll is cheaper, and above it Gusto is.

How much does SurePayroll cost?

SurePayroll Full Service is $29 a month plus $7 per employee. The No Tax Filing plan is $20 a month plus $4 per employee. Local tax filing and multiple state tax filing are $9.99 a month each on Full Service. Checked November 16, 2026.

Is SurePayroll cheaper than Gusto for 10 employees?

Yes, by $10 a month. Ten employees cost $99 a month on SurePayroll Full Service and $109 on Gusto Simple, before any add-ons.

Is Gusto or SurePayroll better?

Gusto for most businesses that want automatic tax filing and benefits included. SurePayroll is worth a look for the tightest budgets or for household/nanny payroll, its strongest niche.

Does SurePayroll file taxes like Gusto?

Only on its Full Service plan. The cheaper No Tax Filing plan leaves filing and deposits to you. Gusto includes automatic tax filing on every plan.

Gusto Payroll overview Gusto FAQs Back to Gusto Discount