Gusto payroll software logo

Payroll Comparison 2026

Gusto vs. Square Payroll

Square Payroll is a great fit if you already run Square for point-of-sale — timecards flow straight from the register into payroll, and at $35 a month plus $6 per person it costs $14 a month less than Gusto Simple. Outside the Square ecosystem, its HR and benefits tooling is lighter than Gusto's. For businesses that aren't tied to Square hardware, Gusto is the more complete payroll and HR platform.

Feature Gusto Square Payroll
Base price $49/mo $35/mo
Per employee $6/employee/mo $6/person/mo
Contractor payroll Plan's per-person fee, only in months paid $6/contractor, no base fee
Payroll tax filing Automatic, all 50 states — included Federal and state filings included
Benefits administration Health, dental, vision, 401(k), HRA Health insurance and 401(k) as add-ons
Time tracking Built in (Plus & Premium) Built in (syncs with Square POS)
Intro offer Free setup, no contract No long-term contract
Support Phone, email, chat Phone & email (business hours)
Best for Small businesses that want payroll + HR + benefits in one place Retail & restaurants already using Square POS

Pricing as of 2026 from each provider's public pricing pages. Confirm current rates before purchasing.

Gusto vs Square Payroll pricing by team size

Square Payroll's full-service plan is $35 a month plus $6 per person. Gusto Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person. Both charge $6 per person, so the gap is the base fee: Square is $14 a month cheaper at every team size, or $168 a year.

If you pay only contractors, Square has no base fee: $6 a month for each contractor you pay.

Team size Gusto Simple Gusto Plus Square Payroll
5 employees $79/mo $140/mo $65/mo
10 employees $109/mo $200/mo $95/mo
25 employees $199/mo $380/mo $185/mo
50 employees $349/mo $680/mo $335/mo
100 employees $649/mo $1,280/mo $635/mo

List prices for employees. Gusto Simple and Square's full-service plan both include payroll tax filing. Gusto checked November 1, 2026, Square checked November 16, 2026.

What the Square Payroll price leaves out

Not much. Square's full-service price includes unlimited pay runs, federal and state tax payments and filings, new-hire reporting, and timecard import from Square POS or the Square Team App. Scheduling is included up to 10 days out. Health insurance and 401(k) are add-ons, and mailing paper W-2s or 1099s costs $3 per form a year.

The extra $14 a month on Gusto does not buy better payroll. It buys Gusto's benefits and HR tools, and on Plus, time tracking that does not depend on a Square register.

Gusto or Square Payroll: a simple rule

Pick Square Payroll if you already take payments on Square, since hours and tips flow from the register into payroll, or if you pay only contractors. Pick Gusto if you do not use Square POS, or if benefits and HR tools matter more to you than $14 a month.

Where Gusto wins

  • Deeper benefits and HR tooling
  • Not locked to one POS ecosystem
  • Stronger onboarding and compliance features

Where Square Payroll wins

  • Seamless if you already use Square POS
  • Costs $14 a month less than Gusto Simple
  • Contractor-only pricing: $6 per person, no base fee

The bottom line

Square Payroll is the obvious pick if your business already runs on Square POS, and it costs $14 a month less than Gusto Simple. Away from Square, Gusto offers deeper benefits and HR and doesn't tie you to one register. Square's contractor-only pricing ($6 per person, no base fee) is hard to beat.

New customers can earn a $100 Visa card for running their first payroll with Gusto. Choose Square Payroll if retail & restaurants already using square pos.

Gusto vs. Square Payroll — FAQs

Is Gusto cheaper than Square Payroll?

No. Square Payroll is $35 a month plus $6 per person and Gusto Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person, so Square is $14 a month cheaper at any team size. Square's contractor-only plan has no base fee.

How much does Square Payroll cost?

Full-service payroll is $35 a month plus $6 per person paid. Contractor-only payroll is $6 per person paid with no monthly base fee. Ten employees cost $95 a month. Checked November 16, 2026.

Does Square Payroll have a contractor-only plan?

Yes. It is $6 a month per contractor paid, with no base fee. Automated federal and state tax payments and filings are on the full-service plan only. Gusto charges its plan's base fee plus the per-person fee.

Should I use Square Payroll or Gusto?

Use Square Payroll if you already run Square POS and want timecards to sync automatically. Choose Gusto if you want deeper benefits and HR, or you're not tied to Square hardware.

Is Gusto better than Square Payroll for employees?

For W-2 employees with benefits, Gusto's broader benefits marketplace and HR tools give it the edge. Square is strongest for retail and restaurant teams already on Square and for contractor-only payroll.

Gusto Payroll overview Gusto FAQs Back to Gusto Discount